Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | My Orble | Login

Legal Herald - by Craig Hill

The Skinny Model Ban

September 18th 2006 10:37
Model, photograph by jesus
A Catwalk Model, from www.morguefile.com


On the 2nd of August 2006, at approximately 9pm, Luisel Ramos stepped off a runway in Montevideo. She was a 22-year-old Uruguayan beauty who was slowly making her mark on the South American modeling front. But this was the last time she would parade down the catwalk, ever.


At approximately 9.15pm that same day, Luisel died from heart failure. She had not eaten for almost two weeks.

Her death has forced the fashion world to confront a harsh reality. And quite frankly, this confrontation was long overdue.

The fact is that some models are just too skinny. They are willingly starving themselves because right now, thin is in. And like a domino effect, males and females of all ages who are being bombarded with images of skinniness are simply following in their footsteps – dieting and developing eating disorders all in the name of beauty.

But Luisel’s death was the final straw for the Spaniards. During Madrid Fashion Week, wafer-thin models were banned from the show after a rule was instituted permitting only those models with a Body Mass Index of 18 or above to participate in the parades. According to the World Health Organisation, a person with an Index less than 18.5 is underweight. So when the average female model is 5”9, this means she will need to weigh at least 57 kg to be allowed to participate - which is still on the thin side for most people’s liking, but at least they are making some progress, right?


Similarly, British Cabinet Minister Tessa Jowell has called for London Fashion Week to adopt the same measures. Not only would this ensure that the health of the models is maintained, but it would also have an effect on all the young men and women who try to emulate these slender figures.

Yet the British Fashion Council has announced that it would not impose a ban on “skinny” models because they do not want to interfere in the aesthetic of their designer’s shows.

And just how many more Luisel Ramos’ must there be before something is done about this?

Clearly, it would be impossible to implement a “law” in this regard, but should there be rules or guidelines banning overly-skinny models from the catwalk?

194
Vote


   

   

   

The content on this site is written and mediated by Craig Hill
Go to Craig Hill's home page by clicking here







   

Comments
14 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Lucy Lucy

September 18th 2006 14:30
She died?? That's terrible!

I think that there should be some "code of conduct" for models including things like not starving yourself and not doing drugs. Not sure if it would solve the problem butmaybe they need the encouragement.

Comment by Cibbuano

September 18th 2006 23:20
I think thin is very unsexy... I'd love to see models with slender, not thin, physiques...

Comment by Legally Brunette

September 19th 2006 02:42
I agree, but I guess fashion designers want these super skinny girls because they can showcase their clothes in a particular way. I reckon if you are a truly good fashion designer, you should be able to make clothes look good on all shapes and sizes no?

Comment by jon

September 19th 2006 03:57
I want to know how she lasted 2 weeks without food! Most people are dead in the water if they skip lunch.

Comment by Trina

September 19th 2006 04:07
I think it's a fair rule, in that it may discourage girls from NOT eating and be a bit more realistic...

Maybe drugs had something to do with it...

Comment by Legally Brunette

September 19th 2006 15:01
A code of conduct incorporating minimum weight standards would be ideal, but in a way, would that be discriminating against people who are naturally thin and by WHO (world health org) standards, underweight? I don't know, maybe some people would object? In fact, I know quite a few people who would definetly object...

Cibbo, I'm with you, i think a bit of curve is really beautiful.

Comment by Ruth

September 20th 2006 01:30
Not to be too morbid but I thought the human body could survive for a longer period without food. I was under the impression that it was more like a month. Lack of water was the real killer. I suppose she wasn't starting from a normal body weight so maybe two weeks is a real threshold if you're not carrying enough spare fatty energy deposits.

I'm surprised she had the energy to walk down the catwalk. It is one hell of a demonstration of mind over matter.

Comment by Legally Brunette

September 20th 2006 02:32
Ruth, I thought that too. I'm pretty sure most people can survive for about a month without food. Unfortunately, Luisel Ramos wasn't most people. It's amazing how much our bodies can put up with but I hope her story encourages young girls to realise just how much they are putting themselves at risk. It's just not worth it.

Comment by Ragin Cajun

September 20th 2006 03:50
I applaud this move by Madrid. I just hope that the industry realizes that these models are people, not coat stands. What's probably more difficult is to change the view that being thin equals being beautiful.

Comment by Legally Brunette

September 21st 2006 13:15
Unfortunately not many oher cities are following in Madrid's footsteps it seems. London, Paris and Milan have all rejected the idea which is a real shame.

And you are definetly right about changing people's views Cajun. Where do we even start? On the catwalk?

Comment by Cathy

October 6th 2006 14:26
It's about time someone takes a stand regarding this thin-craze. I'm sick of hearing these aren't real people. They are real people with messed up self image and messed up gigs that demand their body look a certain way. When people quit accepting this and when men quit oggling at pics of these women, the trend will change. Every man (and every woman) should watch some movies from the 40s and 50's to see what a sexy body really is!!

Please visit me when you get the chance.

Fakes, Frauds and Fools

Comment by Anonymous

March 27th 2007 01:52
UGLY but nice legs

Comment by Joy Grunenwald

July 7th 2007 12:38
I agree but society loves thin. I mean I am not trying to sound sexist but men usually like thin or skinny women. I do not meet many or really any men that prefer the rounder or fuller figure and hence women are trying to please these men? I have several male friends that laugh at the larger woman and I mean anyone that weighs more than 60 kilos. Until women can just be proud of who and what they are then I think the thin craze will continue.

Comment by Anonymous

September 6th 2007 23:16
How many people every day die from heart failure because they're so fat? Too many to count! Whereas this gets in the headlines and now as a man I feel ashamed to say out loud that I think thin women are attractive because it's so un-PC. Not eating for 2 weeks could cause serious illness or death to people of any weight. Anorexia is a terrible psychological illness, but the notion that specifically catwalk models are causing young insecure teenage girls to become anorexic is ridiculous, and simply not true. America and the UK are facing an obesity epidemic. Thin is healthy. An eating disorder is a psychological disease, and is too often confused with being thin.

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Notify extra people about this comment
Is this a private comment?
List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this comment


One per line max of 30

List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this private comment thread. Only the people in this list will be able to see or reply to your comment.


One per line max of 30

Your Name
(for the email going out to the above list, it can be different to your Orble Tag)
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
1 Posts
1 Posts
8 Posts
156 Posts dating from January 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Craig Hill's Blogs

4676 Vote(s)
53 Comment(s)
78 Post(s)
555 Vote(s)
7 Comment(s)
9 Post(s)
41491 Vote(s)
2314 Comment(s)
511 Post(s)
1241 Vote(s)
5 Comment(s)
30 Post(s)
852 Vote(s)
0 Comment(s)
22 Post(s)
2632 Vote(s)
19 Comment(s)
25 Post(s)
Moderated by Craig Hill
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]